Sometimes some incidents change your entire perspective of
looking at things. They even challenge your beliefs and leave you baffled.
Sharing one of such food for thought incident with you:
Last week I received a call from
an old family friend who had just shifted to their new house. After exchanging
the usual pleasantries I asked her how was she feeling in her new locality? She
narrated to me a very recent incident that had happened in her building which
had left her with many doubts in her mind.
Here I would like to mention, she
stays in a four storied apartment with 8 families residing there. The building
is very closely knit, in the sense you can hear your next door neighbour’s TV
clearly and sometimes also catch a glimpse of what is happening in their
drawing room. Just a floor below her lives a 54 year old lady who is an active
social worker with local NGO working for women upliftment. Her next door
neighbour is a South Indian family consisting of mother, father and their young
son. One particular night her neighbours Mr. and Mrs. Pillai had a heated
argument about something in their mother tongue. Though nobody could make out
the reason behind it, their raised tones depicted the quarrel which was taking
place.
| Source: Google Images |
The next day the social worker,
let’s call her Ms. Sharma landed up at their place when Mr. Pillai had gone out
on some domestic chore. Without waiting for any introductions she started
interrogating that lady and told her,’ I
know that man harasses you…please just complain once and see what we do to him.’
Now Mrs. Pillai was a God fearing lady and on hearing this she got scared.
Looking at Ms. Sharma she said,’
No...No…there is nothing like that at all. It was a family matter, nothing
serious. A property dispute going on in the court is pending since last 10
years. You are staying in the building since so long. You also know we never
argue about anything. We have been happily married for the last 30 years.’
Not the one to lose out so soon she continued pestering her when Mrs. Pillai’s son
Abhinav entered the room.
Now Ms. Sharma’s entire focus
shifted to him. She self introduced herself and asked him what he was doing currently.
Before Abhinav could react Mrs. Pillai replied,’ He is working in an MNC bank. We have finalized a girl for his
marriage.’ Mrs. Pillai was silently thanking God as the topic had changed
and the focus was now on her son. Ms.
Sharma’s eyes gleamed as she looked at her and said,’ So everything is sorted?’
Mrs. Pillai nodded and smiled,’ Oh
yes….I told you, it was one of a case otherwise we are a very peace loving
couple.’
Ms. Sharma: No I am talking
about your son’s marriage. Have you discussed everything in details with them?
(Clearing her throat) I mean the give and take.
Mrs. Pillai was getting confused
and had a perplexed look on her face.
Ms. Sharma: Ask at least for
a car I tell you. I know you are so naive; you would not have spoken anything
about it. It’s not very late even now. Please call and let them know. Arre bhai you have only one son. He deserves
the best.
Just as she finished Mrs. Pillai
was staring at her fumbling with words when Abhinav intervened, ‘But Aunty…taking dowry is wrong.’
Ms. Sharma: Who said we are
asking for dowry. We are asking for a wedding gift. Now which father will not
like to give a wedding gift to his daughter? Tell me. A person gets married
only once in lifetime.
Abhinav: (Irritated) I
thought you work for an NGO which deals with women related issues.
Ms. Sharma: Yes I do. We work
against domestic violence against women. See beta you are an only child. You
need to look at your mother’s comfort also. In this age how much running around
will she do in a rickshaw. She needs a car. Listen to me and call them right
now.
Abhinav: (Angrily) I am
capable enough to take care of my mother’s needs. I don’t need anybody else’s
help to fulfill them. [And he left the room]
Ms. Sharma: (gruffly) This is
the problem with today’s generation. They don’t know anything. They cannot even
treat their elders with respect. Saying this she stomped out of their house
much to the shock and dismay of Mrs. Pillai.
I was speechless at the other end
of the phone not knowing what to say. I was wondering which dictionary or law
states accepting gifts from your would be wife’s parents (that too by asking out rightly)
is not considered as dowry. This is the common man of our country. Donning a
new name they have let the pest called dowry easily exist in our society in its
all glory. My friend on the other end cleared her throat to bring back my attention and asked me ,' Now you tell me, how is my new locality?'. The only word I could manage to say was ' Interesting! '
This Ms Sharma is so known to everyone of us...these species are wandering everywhere and unfortunately they are quite strong in their belief of this so called 'wedding gifts' and are not ashamed a bit to put their demands loud....
ReplyDelete:o)
DeleteSo true a statement. Each one of us must be knowing at least one such person around who conveniently puts a mask of 'gift' on the demon of dowry.
duh- taking dowry in any form has become a vicious trap; you know, even if the boy's family don't ask, the girl's family splurges and this put a wrong idea in to many families. awareness & speaking out is the need of the hour !
ReplyDeleteI completely agree. We and only we all together can do something about it .
DeleteI have ample examples around me who just say we dont want anything you can give your daughter anything you want. And the parents give everything from a needle to a double bed, cupboard, fridge etc etc saying it is our custom we cannot let our daughter go empty handed apart from the normal jewellery and all.
For a minute i thought Ms. Sharma was just asking that to cross check and ensure that there was no dowry happening. wasn't it like that?
ReplyDeleteWell sadly toffee that does not seem to be the case here. Because she was trying to explain how his mother needed some level of comfort which only a car that too from the girls side could give. And adding to it further on the next meeting she even proudly told Mrs. Pillai what all she managed to get from her daughter-in-law's place and how she should try convincing her son to agree to ask for atleast a car if nothing more.:)
DeleteI can't believe this can happen.. somebody belonging to an NGO can have a view point like that...
ReplyDeleteBelieve me even I was shocked and angry to an extent that have asked my friendto go and complain against her in the NGO too. But this will end just one such person, imagine how many of these would be around us doing like this and believing it.
DeleteMotivational !Though provoking !Nice write up.
ReplyDeleteThanks :)
DeleteWell hence the reason why i say a women is sometimes the worst enemy of another women and also the so called people who are working for the better of women dont even know what they are doing .. Ridiculous
ReplyDeleteBikram's
Ridiculous is the perfect word I guess Bikram. These women don't understand the damage they are doing to the society or perhaps incase they do they dont want to acknowledge it.
DeleteVery sad state of affairs.
:) Interesting twist in the tale!:)
ReplyDeleteMany people pretend to be intellectual and modern but they have paradoxical opinions. You can read an interesting tale here http://tarangsinha.blogspot.in/2010/11/ironic-opinion.html
Thanks :)
DeleteI agree, on their face they seem to command so much respect but when we see their real colours we cannot stand them leave alone respecting!
Sure...wl read it soon
Aaah, me was waiting for u to tell me what thy were both fighting bout n then u tell me tht the women activist is a dowry dudette :)
ReplyDeleteMust say, interesting place u live in :)
fc klove
Oh yes...a very interesting place don't ask. There seems to be so much happening around me all the while that I could fill books writing about them...he he :)
DeleteHi
ReplyDeleteVery true. Sometimes its better to call it dowry and ask rather than hiding a wolf in a sheepskin and calling it a gift!! Shameful!
Very true. I don't understand what do people derive from all this. The only logic I can think of is they have fallen into the rut of doing it only for the heck of doing it.
DeleteInteresting and scary :)
ReplyDeleteScary indeed it is - the naked truth!
DeleteDoublespeak happens all the while. I'm always a little wary of the motivations of the Mrs Sharmas of the world.
ReplyDeleteI agree to you completely...we need to be wary of such people.
DeleteIndeed, its old wine in a new bottle.
ReplyDeleteI recently remember a friend saying how marriages are seen as financial bargain in their community. A sad affair of relations.
Truly a sad affair. Financial bargain being associated with a term like marriage in itself is a red signal.
Deletehey is this true? a woman working with an NGO advocating dowry? I am very very sad...
ReplyDeleteYes sadly Bhavana it is true. Such people exist around us everywhere
DeleteWow! That's something to think about. There are so many good initiatives in the country that can help eradicate most of the social ills. But unfortunately, as a nation, we seem to lack in sincerity.
ReplyDeleteYes I completely agree to you. We all need to come together and work on this with complete dedication that's when we might be able to eradicate some of these problems from their roots.
DeleteA very Thought provoking post... !!! Well done !!
ReplyDeleteThank you so much for your appreciation :o)
DeleteWelcome here!
And people like them exist everywhere they don't mind their own work but instead are very keen to poke into the nose of neighbors irritatingly and i don't understand how an NGO person who works for Woman Upliftment is talking about accepting Dowry?
ReplyDeleteI know, I get to meet them all and I am sure each one of us finds them somewhere around us.
DeleteI also found this hilarious and I was so tempted to meet her.But then I realized that it is not her fault, she has been brought up with a certain set of beliefs which will take time to change. Our society as a whole believes in such things and hence the trend continues from one generation to other!